Gitto's Pizza

andrea calero 2 months ago

Sooooo disappointed! I just moved to the neighborhood and was happy to see my proximity to this pizzeria. When I would visit Orlando from NY I was happy to eat here since I felt it was the closest to pizza I would get back home. Last night, I ordered a large cheese pie and garlic knots after not having eaten here in years and what I got was a doughy pie with tasteless sauce and the garlic “knots” were anything but. Stale bread with zero garlic, dry with some seasoning. It’s literally sitting in my fridge since I didn’t want to throw it away in front of my husband. I was also not expecting to find 4 of these stale breads inside the pizza box so I guess it came with my 18” pie. It is good business ethic to advise your customers who are ordering a side order of the “garlic knots” that some rolls are already included. Last time I eat here.

Tracee Wyche 2 months ago

If you’re craving some really good pizza, definitely check out Gitto’s! The service was great, they have plenty of pizza options, and the wings were absolutely amazing. ☺️ My mom and I stopped by to celebrate her birthday and were both craving pizza. We couldn’t have picked a better spot. Everything was fresh, delicious, and the staff were very welcoming 🫶🏽. We’ll definitely be back!

Emanuel Salinas 6 months ago

I went into this place hyped since my close brothers prasied this place as the pizza place in downtown. And honestly, they weren't wrong, cus wooo weee it was good, especially the lasagna pizza (sooooo much cheese). And honestly, the vibe of the place felt like classical setting with the mixture of more modern perspectives. Like drawing on the wall and being 2 floors. Fitting the city settings, definitely worth the price for how big the pizzas were.

Jaime Finnegan 7 months ago

Ordered late night Valentine’s Day for work. 3 large pizzas (Pepperoni, Cheese, Hawaiian) they made them heart shaped. Had to wait an extra 15 minutes since someone cut a slice out of one of them which doesn’t make sense as to why someone working there would if you see it’s a special order. Cheese and Pepperoni were good, the Hawaiian one was a little dry, didn’t know they don’t put tomato sauce on their Hawaiian. The bread knots were really good tho. Service is good too, typical laidback NY style pizzeria.

JP Lambiase 7 months ago

Gitto’s Pizzeria in downtown Orlando has been a go-to spot for years and is often mentioned as one of the better pizza options in Florida. What keeps it interesting, though, is how the atmosphere continues to evolve while staying true to its roots. At its core, this is classic New York–style grab-and-go pizza. You order by choosing slices through the glass, with plenty of options that go beyond traditional toppings—standouts like chicken bacon ranch and buffalo-style slices are clearly crowd favorites. The atmosphere is where Gitto’s really shines. From the outside, it looks like a simple hole-in-the-wall, but once inside, there’s more personality and energy than you’d expect. The complimentary garlic knots were an unexpected and appreciated bonus. The dough is flavorful and familiar—exactly what you want from a NYC-style slice. I ordered the chicken bacon ranch, and it delivered: not overly sauced (which is key, since ranch can easily overpower), perfectly cooked bacon, and solid chicken that didn’t taste frozen or pre-made. Pizza is subjective, and this is just my experience—but it’s important to judge Gitto’s for what it is. This is New York grab-and-go pizza, not Italian, C